Stop Using No Pain - No Gain in your rehab
Why you shouldn't use "No Pain, No Gain" in your rehab.
Recently a client came to me with significant pain in their knee, which was not settling with all their rehab - which, was, on reflection a good programme. However, they were more of a "safety first? Nah, coffee, lawns and the garden, then safety" kind of person. I asked a few more questions to get deeper into it. They were doing all the rehab, exactly as they should, but pushing the exercises as hard as they could go. They had looked at the rehab programme, but not the instructions on how hard to go, which was to keep their pain at less than a 2/10 increase in pain and this trumped 7-8/10 in muscle activation. They had seen 7-8/10 effort and run with it and used "no pain no gain" as their guiding principle. . (So many people do this, so I've done a video on it - they just hadn't looked at it).
The base idea for how I rehab patients - do as much as you can possibly do, with no increase in pain. Side note: this will change based on what has happened in your day/week, including stress, fuel, hydration, other exercise, sleep and overall health.
Again, for those in the back, chatting.
Your aim isn't to find the absolute maximum amount you can tolerate.
Because that doesn't give you the wins you are after. It makes you feel like you are getting somewhere, but I can promise you (after watching people do this since 2002) you are spinning your wheels.
So, here's what you need to do
You want to get load as high as possible without flaring.
We want you doing as much of the things you love and as much of your rehab as possible, without increasing your discomfort - (you are avoiding the deep mud and not hitting anything that causes you to lose any traction - it's the best way to move forward).
If you get a flare, you will find everything can start to grumble away even with day to day things. You then need to Settle again, and Deload, before you Reload.
A flare is like getting stuck in mud - you have missed the point at which you should stop, and then you need some strategies to get back on the track. (this is where my "Settle-Deload-Reload" system comes in).
Your goal is to stay underneath the " flare up line" as much as possible (a moveable data point of how much activity you can cope with, and recover from) where everything becomes cranky .
We always plan to go from one point to the other with the least detours. But, we are human, and sometimes detours find us (an unexpected muddy patch), and other times, we find that patch because it looks like fun.
I also expect my clients to go over that line, because I see a special subset of humans that go "full mutton" and "no ears" in their lives, because they need to do cool things. I don't growl (and I'll often ask if it was awesome, and find some details out about the thing, and we decide if the pain flare is worth it based on how cool the thing you did is).
I think of these moments of flare/skidding as a learning opportunity -
Did it look like it was going fine and you slipped sideways, or
did it look like it was going to be something to watch out for and you did it anyway?
What was the outcome?
Was it the same as every other time? Or
Did you somehow learn something?
Another way to look at constantly pushing for a flare (no pain - no gain) and not working under the flare-up line is as if you are that special set of pet sheep (or any sheep) testing the fence every couple of weeks - for them it's to find a way out, for human's it's just to "check" for a jump in capacity, - "can I do this yet?" - it's a valid thing to check but can come at a cost.
Sometimes the answer to "can I do this yet" is a surprising yes, and you find you can push it (but sometimes you can do the new thing only once per week , and not three times especially at the start) and sometimes your body is ready to hit the gas again.
Going over this line (or through this fence, to continue the analogy, or to keep skidding (to butcher the analogy)) - gives you information - I can do this/I can't do this, but constantly testing isn't how we get an increase in capacity.
My note here - it's worth testing, but not every week. If we are flaring every week, we aren't working to our best capacity and we aren't progressing. It seriously slows rehab progression if you are constantly spinning your tyres and not getting anywhere.
Even with support, my clients often slide off track.
If you need a bit of guidance (a tractor and a bungee tow rope (they are my fave)) because your injury is not progressing, I've got lots of tricks for getting you back doing the things you want, using rehab as a tool rather than making rehab your whole new personality.
Side note: You don't need to be a "full mutton/no ears" client to work with me.
If this sounds like what you need, book a 1:1 with me - where we can decide if traditional physiotherapy (online or in person), or a progressive rehab programme is the best fit for you.


